Instructional Intelligences (based on Barrie Bennett & Carol Rolheiser, Beyond Monet, 2001)

Instructional Concepts

Concepts which have dramatic effects on engaging students in learning. 

Act as guides...not something a teacher can physically do.

Active Participation

Structuring of content and strategies that promote students' active involvement in learning such as the use of strategies like Role Playing and Cooperative Learning (ties into Individual Accountability).

Engaging students at appropriate levels of difficulty (so they can experience success).

Integration of other motivational concepts (see Motivation: 'Six Characteristics') below.

Motivation

Anything that encourages a student to learn.

Two Types:

Intrinsic - Force comes from within the learner

Extrinsic - Force comes from outside the learner (teachers use skills, tasks, strategies to move students to intrinsic).

Six Characteristics:

1. Success: not boring, not too difficult/easy

2. Knowledge of Results: feedback - checking for understanding, rubrics

3. Accountability:

      Increasing accountability - framing the question, wait time,  learning standards

      Visibility - moving around the room increases the chance students will be involved

      Consequences - enjoying fruits of their effort or consequences of not completing task

      Time - right amount of time to complete work increases intensity of effort

      Help - knowing avenues of help exist reduces level of concern (guided practice)

4. Meaningful to the Student: linking to their experience

5. Positive Feeling Tone: wining over, politeness

6. Interest: novelty, vividness, variety

Levels of Thinking (Bloom's Taxonomy)

Knowledge (recall, recite) - least complex

What is the definition for...?

Trace the pattern...

Recall the facts...

Name the characters of...

List the steps for...

   

Comprehension (explain, provide examples)

   

Tell why these ideas are similar.

Provide some examples.

Construct a model of...

In your own words retell the story of....

Classify these concepts. (could also be analysis)

Draw a picture to...or role-play what happened.

   

Application (act on understanding)

Graph the data.

Demonstrate the way to...

Practise...

 Act out the way a person would...

Calculate the...

   

Analysis (compare/contrast, pull apart)

   

How would you make a...?

The solution would be to...

What is the pattern of...?

If...then...

What are the components of...?

The difference between the fact and the hypothesis is...?

What is the relationship between... and...?

Which steps are important in the process of...?

What other conclusions can you reach about... that

    have not been mentioned?

   

Synthesis (reinvent, create, look at in a new way)

   

Make an hypothesis about...

Make an hypothesis about...

Change... so that it will...

Prescribe a new way to...

Finish the incomplete story so that...

Change... so that it will...

Create a model that shows you new ideas.

Devise an original plan or experiment for...

Evaluation (judge based on criteria) - most complex

In your opinion...

Appraise the chances for...

Grade or rank the...

What solution do you favour and why?

Which systems are best? worst?

Rate the relative value of these ideas to...

Simple to Complex and Easy to Difficult Continuums

Covert to Overt

Covert means hidden from public view.  It is useful because it increases success and a sense of safety because students can rehearse.

  Close your eyes and pretend you are...

  Visualize...Imagine...

  See it in your mind's eye...

  Think to yourself...

  Rehearse in your mind...

Overt means not hidden from public view.  It is useful because it holds students accountable to think and to participate.

   

 

  Discuss with your partner...

  Thumbs up if you agree...

  Write your answer...

  Share your answer with the class...

  Act out your feelings...

Fear of Failure and Dependency

A classroom should never be perceived by students as "not safe" or "too safe".

  Understanding how to respond to students, asking questions at different levels of complexity, wait

     time are very important in helping students feel safe and challenged.

Accountability and Level of Concern

The art of teaching is deciding what level of student concern to evoke (from little to high anxiety) and what level of accountability to evoke (no involvement to full involvement) to maximize learning.

     

1. High Level of Concern & High Level of Accountability

     

     The teacher asks students to think to themselves first and then tells them he will select two

          or three students to respond.

     

2.  Low Level of Concern & High Level of Accountability

     

      The teacher asks students to think to themselves first and then share with a partner before

          their thinking with the class.

     

3.  Low Level of Concern & Low Level of Accountability

     

      The teacher asks students if anyone could answer the question. Teacher waits for

          someone to respond.

4.  High Level of Concern & Low Level of Accountability

      The teacher randomly selects several students to respond to questions - that response is

          made in front of the class.